Serial non-monogamist Alex is insulted when best friend Ben mentions going on more than one date with the same girl, Holly, but her induction into the group goes better than expected when third bestie Kate joins the picture.
Alex enlists Holly for help with Ben’s birthday. Kate meets the Faith Hill to her Tim McGraw (online) but has second thoughts after meeting her IRL. Holly’s sorority friend Clarissa brings some interesting things to light.
Kate and Alex are both falling for girls they don’t want to fall for, so Alex enlists her ex Gina to keep Holly at bay, but the plan doesn’t go quite as...planned. Ben is the only one paying attention at Helen Hunt movie night.